Press "Enter" to skip to content

The Poor Historian

Credit Shelbyroot on Flickr

Last week, I was listening to the cases that were admitted by the overnight resident. By the time he presented the third case, I became annoyed after I repeatedly heard the dreaded phrase “poor historian.” This particular patient wasn’t forthcoming with his symptoms. He was vague with what was going on. “He couldn’t provide an accurate history.” The patient was a homeless man who came to the emergency room feeling unwell and coughing up blood. He had a rip-roaring pneumonia.

I stopped the resident and told him bluntly “the reason the patient can’t give a history is because he is very sick! You too would give a poor history, if you had strep pneumonia bacteria coursing in your blood. ”

The resident had also incorrectly used the term. The historian is the by definition, the one who takes the history. The resident had done a poor job and had blamed the patient for his own deficiencies.

In Jayshi’s Patel JAMA’s piece “The Things We Say” he recounts his own experience with this term.

Later, when I ignored the term and began to pay attention, I concluded encephalopathy, dementia, depression, frustration, anxiety, and anger were reasons why patients did not provide an accurate history. In fact, there was always a reason why the patient wouldn’t or couldn’t provide a history. I learned that a patient’s inability to provide a history should not limit my ability to correctly obtain one.

Whenever I hear the phrase poor historian, I try to teach that there are always ways to get a thorough history. There is collateral history we can take from a patient’s family and friends. There are written notes by the paramedics who are usually the first to the scene. There are old medical charts and electronic records we can peruse. We can examine the patients and phrase our questions in ways they can understand and respond to. Rather than grilling the patient, “we can use open-ended questions, pauses, silence, and active listening, to allow the patient to tell the whole story” writes Dr. Tiemstra. The historian isn’t just a scribe – they are the person who organizes the past events and details, and reorganizes the story in a way that makes sense.

When I went to see the patient in the emergency room, I saw a man who was lethargic and breathing hard. “I feel sick doc,” he said in a weak voice. There was nothing more needed to be said. He had given me an accurate history.

(Visited 838 times, 1 visits today)


    ORTO-KRAK June 18, 2018

    I warmly welcome! A great blog for a long time here I go and read these interesting entries, I am in medical school for 3 years and I like to read blogs that give me motivation. It’s nice if something appears more often, I will be very grateful for any new entries! And this one, as usual, great and made me think very much, I greet you warmly!

  2. Megz
    Megz July 16, 2018

    Hi there. This might seem a bit out of the blue, but just over seven years ago, you left a comment on one of my blog posts, where I wrote about how much I hated anatomy.
    You told me it would get better once I saw it in a living, breathing patient.
    I just wanted to say thanks for that, all those years ago. I just wrote a post today, giggling about how naive I was back then. I really appreciate that you offered that advice – which, obviously, was entirely correct.

Leave a Reply to ORTO-KRAK Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published.